gymn
Digest
Sun, 31 Jul 94 Volume 2 :
Issue 155
Today's Topics:
2nd Place AA
ABC coverage (2 msgs)
A little about myself
AP & other wire reports
delay on address
eating disorders
GG, women's team
GG, W team again
Goodwill Game Competitors
Goodwill Games (womens team comp)
Goodwill Games Coverage
Goodwill Thoughts
Gymnastics at CMU..
Gymnastics Coverage / Commentators
Henrich
Henrich's funeral
Henrich/Bulimia/etc.
Jennie Thompson
Karolyi On Henrich
List of AA & EF Qualifiers???
Michelle Campi
More
Henrich Info (from the Chicago Tribune) (2 msgs)
More Info on Henrich
Non-Goodwill Gym On TV
Proposed NCAA Women's Changes
Results: GG, Women's team
TBS coverage
UNIVISION broadcasts before ABC
US Goodwill Games TV Schedule (2 msgs)
This
is a digest of the gymn@athena.mit.edu mailing list.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 94 17:04:31 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: 2nd Place AA
"Fabrichnova finished second with
39.025 and Miller was third with 38.875."
Susan
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 94 18:45:20 EDT
From: <***@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu>
Subject:
ABC coverage
Well, I just finished watching ABC's coverage of the first 2 rotations
of
women's team finals. First of all, I wonder if
it occurred to ABC that not
everyone has cable
and will be able to watch the last 2 rotations (I hope!) on
TBS tonight?
It seems a pretty silly way to cover the event, and I feel bad for
all gym fans who don't get TBS. It would be more logical to
cover the whole
event, even if you do end up
duplicating some TBS coverage. I'm already
frustrated
by ABC's coverage, but I would be just beside myself with irritation
if I didn't get TBS. So why am I frustrated? Well, it would
have been nice to
have seen at least ONE Romanian,
considering they ended up finishing second,
and
since this is all taped coverage, you'd think ABC would know that. I also
would have liked to have seen some Chinese and Spanish
girls, and the
individual competitors (Piskun, Chusovitina, Kuznetsova, etc.) If it hadn't
been
for Sherwin's post, we wouldn't have even KNOWN there were individuals!
>From
what we saw, it looked like Russia, Ukraine and the US were the only teams
there, until ABC would flash the standings, and there was
Romania - always in
2nd or 3rd. SO SHOW US SOME OF THEIR ROUTINES! I just
hope TBS does a better
job tonight... I was also
surprised that Kathy Johnson would make such a huge
blunder
to say that Shannon was reigning world champ on bars, when Shannon
didn't even make bars finals in Brisbane! Perhaps Kathy
meant Shannon was
reigning world AA champ, but it
sure came out sounding like she was world
champion
on bars. And, of course, the mispronunciation of the ex-Sovs
names
drove me crazy. I just don't understand why
commentators don't bother to ASK a
native Russian
speaker (and there are certainly plenty of them around in St.
Pete!) how to pronounce the names. It's just common courtesy, if
you ask me. So
for the record, it's Ko-chet-KO-va
and KNEEZH-nik, and the initial "K" IS
pronounced (otherwise it wouldn't be there! Just 'cause
English uses a silent
"k" doesn't mean
Russian does). Okay, I feel a little better now having gotten
that off my chest. I hope TBS's coverage won't create a need
for further
ranting!
Beth
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 94 21:09:54 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: ABC
coverage
What disappointed me most is that the coverage startd out quite well.
They
went straight from one routine to
another without the fluff.
Unfortunately,
it didn't last...
>Well,
it would have been nice to have seen at least ONE
Romanian,
considering they ended up finishing
second,
and since this is all taped coverage,
you'd think ABC would know that
It seemed to me as if they had 8
rotations (2 times 4 in each rotation) with
the
US, Russia and Ukraine in one 'flight'; and Romania, Spain, China and the
individuals in the other. I still do think they could have fit the
Romanians
in. I was particularly looking forward
to seeing Ghimpu again!
>I hope TBS's
coverage won't create a need for further
ranting!
All
of Beth's rants seem well deserved, but as this is ABC, we knew that in
advance :(
Mara
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 94 22:05:35 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: A little about
myself
Hello, my name is Jessica, I am 12
years old and am a former gymnast
at Gymagic Gymnastics in Sacramento, CA. I was a level 9 when
I quit 18
months ago. I love the sport of gymnastics, and hope
I can keep in touch
with it by gymn. I live in Davis, CA, and do miss the
sport a lot.
------------------------------
Date: Sat, 30 Jul
1994 13:52:32 -0700 (PDT)
From: ***@netcom.com
Subject: AP & other
wire reports
Beside gymn I have been
following the swimming at goodwill.
Seeme the
filter for the pool went haywire and the water turned nearly black.
The
pool got nicknamed "the black lagoon". Competition resumed as soon as
visibility reached 2 feet. The swedes refused to swim in that stuff
so they
resigned. The guy who has been winning, has been
nicknamed
"the creature of the black
lagoon"
Though it would be funny to share. Now back to gymn !
Sad to hear of the death.
Out here in the bay area it
has touched off a storm of controversy about
how gymn is bad because it forces young girls to do bad things
to their bodies.
Mixed press reports , some
say it was her fault, others blame the sport
because
it went on for several years and was not solve imediately.
It
has been pointe dout that interest in womens gymn has skyrocketed in
response
to the younger ages. Is there really a tie here
? Or is it a coincidence
that
womens gymn is getting younger while the audiences rise in numbers
?
Anybody able to tackle this one ?
To
our new biomed person :
Has anyone studied
the effects of heavy training on preteen girls bodies?
What about their skeletons ? Are
there deformations ?
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 1994 06:35:18 -0500 (CDT)
From: <***@owlnet.rice.edu>
Subject:
delay on address
USA Gymnastics is still looking for the appropriate
address -- ie, no,
I didn't forget. They should get it sometime today, they
said. I'll
post
it ASAP.
Rachele
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 94 19:53:47 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: eating
disorders
> I would also hope that everyone refrains from making
nasty comments about
weight gain in former
gymnasts. Some mention is nice, just so we all have a
mental
picture of what the person looks like. As a person who gained plenty
of weight after leaving gymnastics, I don't think it's very
positive or good
for younger competitors to hear
degrading comments about Kim Z. or any others
who
have gained weight
This is an *excellent* point. Kim has been a major victim lately, as
has
Henni Onodi (after
her picture appeared in IG earlier this year). It really
is
nothing but nastiness.
Mara
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 1994 14:41:42 -0500 (CDT)
From: <***@owlnet.rice.edu>
Subject:
GG, women's team
Some small tidbits from the AP wire:
The
competition is being held at the Lenin Sport and Concert Complex.
Aside
from listing the team scores, this particular AP report only
says that the USA team had a "mixed" performance
and that Miller
"disappointed on her favorite
routine of beam" but got a 9.95 in the
floor
ex, the highest mark of the night on all apparatus. (I wonder
if
she's gotten a new routine yet?)
Rachele
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 1994 15:11:00 -0500 (CDT)
From: <***@owlnet.rice.edu>
Subject:
GG, W team again
Yes, more Goodwill Games news:
>From
Reuters:
-The worst Russian score on floor was 9.775 (I don't know
who.)
-"The Americans performed indifferently
throughout."
-Chinese gymnast Dinli Fun
(what a great name) fell on her left elbow
from
the uneven bars while warming up and had to withdraw.
-Lu Li, CHN, currect world champ on UB, only scored a 9.575.
>From
the AP wire:
Miller's scores: 9.725 VT -- two slight missteps.
9.675 UB
9.525 BB (the AP wrote "9.525 on the
beams")
9.950 FX -- highest score of the
night
Dina Kochetkova had 39.15 points;
Miller was third with 38.875.
And
no, of course they don't say who was
2nd.
------------------------------
Date: Fri, 29 Jul 94
16:09:53 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Goodwill Game Competitors
As
suspected neither Gogean nor Milos is competing for Romaina (heard much
earlier
that they were sending a "B" team) and the recently operated on
Vitali Scherbo also is out (even
when there was an appearance fee involved
... he
must be crushed!!!). More surprisingly absent (according to this
article anyway) is Ivan Ivankov.
Hmm?
Susan
------------------------------
Date: Sat,
30 Jul 94 20:55:21 BST
From: ***@ic.ac.uk
Subject: Goodwill Games (womens team comp)
Hello everybody! I've just
finished watching the Goodwill Games
womens
team comp live on TV from the German Sports channel DSF,
so
I thought I'll put in a few words about the meet. The commentary
was in German and I don't know German so all the following
impressions
are my own only and please forgive if
I got any facts wrong!
First some general impressions: It was better
than I thought! Maybe
because the 'Soviets' treat
this very seriously (being in home ground
and all)
and sent full strength teams to the meet. Here are the teams:
Russia : Dina Kochetkova, Svetlana Khorkina,
Oksana Fabrichnova,
Elena Grosheva
Ukraine : Liliya
Podkopayeva, Irina Boulakhova,
Oksana Knizhnik,
Tatiana Malaya
USA :
Shannon Miller, Jennie Thompson, Mariana Webster,
Soni Meduna
Romania :
Andrea Cacovean, Ana Maria Bican,
Angela Ghimpu,
Ionela Loaies
China : Luo Li, Zhang Li, Jin Yu
Spain : Monica Martin,
Veronica Castro, Elizabet Valle
Individual
Participants:
Russia : Evgenia
Kuznecsova
Uzbekistan :
Oksana Chusovitina
Belarus : Elena Piskun
Kazakstan : Irina Evdokimova
Belgium :
Vanessa van de Plas
Her are the
rules: (from what I see and think so it may well be
wrong!)
Only the top three scores count for each team in team
comp
(therefore some teams only sent three representatives) but
a team can have all four of their performers perform on the
same
piece of apparatus. (e.g.
all four Romanians did their VT, but
only three
did the FX... Cacovean didn't). The individual
participants
did their routines to try to qualify
for the AA and Apparatus finals
(I think).
The TV coverage was alright, lots of close-ups which I like, but they
don't seem to give us the scores very often. In fact I have
no idea
whats' happening score-wise during the whole competition. I won't
go
into much details describing the routines since
they're more or less
the same as Worlds'94 and
Europeans'94 (and the German commentary didn't
help
me at this point!) The comp organisation was a bit
iffy I think,
there are a lot of long pauses when
there is nothing happening in the
arena with
gymnasts waiting by their apparatus ready to perform.
So here are some
general thoughts, I particularly concentrated on the
Americans since I
believe that is what most of you guys would like to
hear
about?
Jennie Thompson was in tears before the comp began. She sat on
her VT
warm-up and that was what she did in her
first competition vault.
Things didn't improve as she put her hands down on
her second. Her
vault was 1/2-twist Yurchenko, BTW. Miller took two large steps in her
first VT for only 9.575 (One of only TWO scores that I have
in the whole
comp!) but
her second was better with one step. Meduna began her
run-up
only to be called back because the 'green
light' was not on. (I heard
Nunno said 'Wait for
the green light.')
Boulakhova fell off her
beam, and so did Chusovitina. Ana Maria Bican
did a nice looking
double-twisting Yurchenko for VT. It has not
been
Andrea Cacovean's year.
She got stuck in her bars mid-way through and
had
to stop-and-go, and she fell off her beam in the flick-layout to two
feet combination. Maybe that's why she didn't compete on FX
because
that was her last piece of apparatus and
she had no chance of getting
into the AA? Khorkina also fell off her roundoff-layout
combo on BB.
Jennie Thompson's second piece wasn't much better as she
sat on her
dismount from bars. In beam though she
did OK with a standing full-twist
back somi, and a full-in dismount. No problems there. Miller's
BB was
iffy with a big wobble at the end of her
flick-layout-layout, and two
large steps back on
her full-in dismount.
Ionela Loaies looks more beautiful by the minute... oh sorry, back
to
the gymnastics... Only saw her FX and VT and
they're kind of alright,
no
thrills job. Angela Ghimpu has a face that looks like
wanting to cry
all the time... then at one point
she laughed. Weird. Bican was much
taller than I remember her but she's pretty good, with a
nice double-
twisting Yurchenko
on VT.
Podkopayeva was classy as always, and
Knizhnik looked really good. If
only she can loosen up a little, she seemed very tense
throughout.
Boulakhova was OK and Malaya only did
two routines, but her bars was
excellent (Marinich; Jaeger; full-in back-out dismount).
Piskoun was more or less the same as Europeans, but she
didn't fall off
this time and did a good
double-twisting-Yurchenko vault. Oksana 'still-
going' Chusovitina was more or
less the same too.
Fabrichnova has a new FX
(I haven't seen her FX for over a year so it's
bound
to be new) with new music sort of pop style. She has a good BB still
too. Khorkina was still very
different from all the others with her long
lines
and very different skills and routines. Kochetkova's
routines were
the same as in Worlds and Europeans.
Grosheva too still had a good bars.
Kuznecsova looks like a junior and only did BB (and she wear a different
leotard than
all the other Russians). BTW, the Russians are wearing the
white/red/blue leotard and only Kuznecsova
wear the black one that they
used in Worlds and
Europeans'94.
The Spanish didn't thrill much. They all seem quite big.
They were bottom
(out of the six) from start to
finish.
The Chinese did nice bars, but had one or two of them being
stuck in the
middle of their routines. They only
showed Luo Li's beam so I didn't know
what their general qualities on that piece of apparatus
is.
Last rotation and Jennie Thompson did a nice floor (three whips to
double
twists (or was it triple?); full-in pike;
and triple twists for dismount).
And Shannon Miller did the same old floor
of hers but very well this time
to score a high
9.95! (The other of the two scores that I got!)
The team results:
1.
Russia
2. Romania
3. Ukraine
4. USA
5. China
6. Spain
(I
didn't even have the scores for these!)
For the individual standings
after the team comp, they didn't say, all
I know is the positions after
THREE pieces of apparatus was
1. Kochetkova, 2. Fabrichnova, 3.
Bican, 4.
Grosheva,
5. Podkopayeva.
(I think) but Miller has FX
as her last piece so don't whether she'd
moved up
to the top five...
Anyway hereth ends a very
iffy report (due to lack of understandable
commentary
to help me) but I hope this'll help those who couldn't see
this meet to get a fairly good idea of what had been going
on.
More to come tomorrow for the womens AA.
Sherwin
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 1994 18:45:04 -0400
From: ***@cykick.jvnc.net
Subject:
Goodwill Games Coverage
I suppose it's time to "fire away"
at the TV coverage - again. Although
I
haven't been able to watch all that much of the
TBS coverage (although
virtually everything has
been taped thus far), I did watch this afternoon's
stuff
on ABC. Sorry to say, this is not
ABC's finest work by far:
- How long did it take for Bart & Kathy
to get around to providing SCORES???
Then again, maybe they were working with the folks from German TV. ;-)
_ To
add insult to injury, did anyone catch either commentator IDENTIFYING A
SINGLE VAULT??? I found it frustrating hearing Kathy
(often) saying
something
like, "She
does this vault so well."
WELL, WHICH VAULT IS IT?
- Although we've often discussed how
difficult it is to watch a meet
because so
many things
take place simultaneously, this coverage seems much more
disjointed than
usual. And I'm not even placing the
entire blame on "the
usual stuff" - breakaways for features and other
competitions. Maybe it's
just me.
Anyway,
that should be enough to start things off...
Helena Robinson
htr@cykick.jvnc.net
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 94 23:40:55 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Goodwill
Thoughts
Well Shannon has put on about 5 pounds that she really needed
- she was
downright skeletal there for a bit - and
physically looks healthy (a tan and
everything
<gasp of shock>) but just seemed ... well ... out of it ... as did
all the Americans.
Nerves seemed high with this young team. I'm a bit
surprised since I've seen all of them separately looking
pretty good and
you'd have thought that a
"team" spirit would help calm them since they all
train together every day.
I am truly ticked that
all of Steve's gymnast do that oh-so-cheap back dive
quarter
turn (the Milosovici oak tree thing <g> ... not
a true Omelianchik
which
is a 1/4 turn swing to hip"catch" crosswise
on the beam) not once but
*twice* in each of their
beam sets. What's even worse is that they don't even
do
it well. U-G-L-Y!
BTW Kathy, Shannon does *NOT* do that vault (Yurchenko layout - or in
Shannon's case *piked* - 1/2) "better then anyone in the world."
I am
constantly annoyed how they point out every
little fault on the foreign
athletes and the
American's only make "little errors." I don't mind pointing
out faults (obviously <g>) but be consistent about it
please. 99% of the TV
audience get 100% of their
information via TV commentators and if they're
inaccurate
how will they (meaning John/Jane Q. Public) ever learn to judge
who's the best for themselves?
Also a broken toe
(meaning Jennie Thompson ... and this is nothing against
her
I just hate it when commentators make endless excuses for the athletes)
is so common ... not that it doesn't hurt ... but geez ... I
mean when
*didn't* Bogie have at least four?
That'll teach her to point her toes while
running
(Svetlana that is). Her feet must be as pretty close up as her hands
are (Eeek!).
Another note
on Jennie ... I totally agree with Kathy that she (Jennie) can't
be allowed to brood over her performance today. She does
have a lot of talent
and I question the thought
process behind making her a Sr. so young (what
does
that really gain her since she can't compete in Worlds or Olympics
anyway ... to me it would seem wiser to keep at small Int'l
meets in the US
and abroad and build to the big
ones). She can't let this haunt her in the
future
and the media shouldn't dwell on this as a major failure but just a
first step in her Int'l career.
The Russian's were amazing!!
They were not only lovely but consistent (who'd
a thunk it? ... Trevor Low's
classic line after '93 Jr's "Khorkina
was
stunning ... beautiful ... but she couldn't
step off a bus without falling
down") Grosheva's Jagger and Tkatchev were the best I've seen since Fan Di in
'89
(and Grosheva's was piked
making it an "E" vs a "D"
... which is what
the straddle is worth now)
I really like Bican - and to
a lesser degree Ghimpu - more then the average
(or should I say "typical?") Romanian.
Fab's disco music has got to go ... but her dance was okay
... considering
what she had to work with.
Grosheva's Thomas (the double twisting laidout
front) is downright amazing.
It was higher and cleaner then most girl's front fulls. I don't think
I've
ever even seen Neil do it that well (sorry
all you Brits out there)!! She
doesn't really have "dance" as such (a lot like Khorkina) but she moves
beautifully
... very fluid.
Khorkina's tumbling looks
much improved (stunning triple twist and that is
the
best front pass going ... front full into front layout step-out) but
while her body line and extension (oh those leaps!) are incredible
she looks
bored and distracted during her
"dance" (mostly looking around and aimless
posing
... she kinda' walks from point to point). A girl with this bod,
line, and attitude (not to mention some Russkie
ballet training) should
really move more comfortably
on the floor. Does her pike position scare
anyone
else as much as it does me? She is *so* stiff legged.
Is Kochetkova's routine getting dorkier or is it just that all
the other
Russians are so much better now? She is *it* for sticking landings
though.
Edwikomova really doesn't get the
credit for that layout front vault that she
deserves.
Way cool. Has any other girl ever attempted that? The only other
person I can even think of doing that vault is Novikov.
Piskun is still
improving. That's truly what I like
best about this gymnast.
Every time I see her she's better then the last
time I saw her. I really
can't think of any other
gymnast - ever - that I can honestly say that
about.
Knischnik is quite
powerful considering that concentration camp physique of
hers
(can you say "Rhythmic" boys and girls?). She may have only done a
tuck
full-in mount and a double tuck dismount they
were high and easy for her and
you could tell that
she is capable of much more. From a
distance with her
hair in a bun she looks like a
'78 Kathy Johnson.
BTW, Castro was *not* second in the Jr. Euros (Letita Begue of France was).
Bart
is on drugs. That also explains why
he can't even pronounce names I've
heard him say
correctly before (Coq au vin? ... maybe he's hungry)
Speaking of Spain
... they are really improving. Their form and hand
positions
rival the best in the world (toe point to die for ... they must
have a whole class devoted totally to breaking their feet
over and over so
that they can do that) Mercedes Pacheco - whom we did not see here - has
some super duper keen bars (bronze ... I think ... in
Euros).
I'm ticked that they cut away from that cool little Russian
kid (with that
punch into immed.
slow front walkover/something-or-other ... what would
you
really call that?) Kuznetkova
<sp?> on beam to show Soni on floor. Nothing
against
Soni, it's just that her set is nice but not all that
unique and
innovative ... unlike my spelling
:-)
About the coverage ... TBS is "feeding" the world and
they're playing 3 on
(US, UKR, & RUS) and 4 off (CHN, ESP, ROM, &
Mixed) which is why I'm sure we
didn't see the
others in ABC"s limited time. I'm surprised that ABC so
drastically chopped the coverage. I mean they had the
control, so to speak,
and yet still appeared so
utterly clueless. I think the public would have
been
far better served if they'd whipped up a condensed - *complete* -
highlight reel for ABC and leave the more in-depth stuff to
TBS. ABC's
coverage looked like they had no idea
where they going with it. TBS's
handling of the last two rotations was pretty good. Of
course by that time
we'd already missed China on
bars and beam and other assorted stuff I would
have
liked to see.
If Bart says
"the competition is fast and furious" or Kathy says "I can't
tell you how
hard that move is" one more time I'll scream. Dear lord it's
only the first day and I'm already this bitter ... what to
do ... what to do?
;-)
Finally Shannon's floor ...
very nicely done. Exceptionally clean on all the
landings
but the difficulty wasn't anywhere near Grosheva, Khorkina, Pod,
or
others.
It was done as well as I've ever seen Shannon do it but a 9.95 was
really out there considering that Khorkina
got a 9.85 for twice the
difficulty (though
admittedly she had more fudged landings and misc. other
deductions).
I just frankly don't think that Shannon's set should be worth a
9.95
compared to some of the others we saw.
She is in desperate need of a
new set.
Waiting
to hear what the rest of you thought ...
Susan
PS- I like how
they said Baryshnikov "immigrated" to the west ;-)
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 1994 00:17:01 -0400 (EDT)
From: <***@gateway.us.sidwell.edu>
Subject:
Gymnastics at CMU..
Once of the universities
I'm considering applying to for next fall is CMU,
(Carnegie Mellon
University) however I believe that they have no
gymnastics
program there. I was wondering if
anyone on the list either
goes to CMU and can give
me more information, or lives in Pittsburgh and
could
tell me about nearby (perferably walking distance) gymns. I
would
like to go there a great deal, and I would
prefer it if I could
participate in gymnastics
while there. They seem weel equipped in every
other
way, but someone really should mention this flaw to them ;).
Thanks.
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 94 23:34:17 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Gymnastics
Coverage /
Commentators
I'd have to agree with everyone else's
comments on the poor coverage by ABC.
While they did show a little bit of
the Romanians and Chinese on TBS, it was
far too
little.
Also, Kathy Johnson drives me nuts! She is completely obsessed
with toe
point, although she was more restrained
than usual today. Also, when a
gymnast makes a
mistake, she'll rarely say what exactly what went wrong. For
example, when Shannon missed her double layout on bars she
simple fawned over
Shannon and how incredible it was that she pulled it
around (which is true)
but she never said why she
had a problem.
Actually, there's a second purpose to this note. My father
is interviewing
Tim Dagget next week. He (my
father, not Dagget) writes for the Insider
section of TV Guide among other things and he'll be writing
on the US
Nationals (the articles have to be written many weeks before
they're actually
published). It's not yet certain
who will cover the meet with Dagget. It may
be Elfie Schlegal - I usually
butcher her name - but that isn't definite yet.
I was wondering who you'd
like to see be the female anaylst? Also, what do
you think of Dagget? I personally
think he's the best one out there. Bart is
pretty
good too, but he's paired with Kathy "Toe Point" Johnson, so that
sort
of colors my perception of him. I like Elfie,
too. She's not awful. But I
think Tim does fine on
his own. True, he gets far too excited sometimes, and
he
definitely has phrases he uses too much like "Shades of Kim Zmeskal!" But
overall
he's pretty good.
What do you all think?
Lee :)
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 94 02:22:37 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Henrich
First off let me say that I have the
utmost repsect for Christy and my heart
goes out to her family and friends.
There really
is no "light" side to this tradgedy but the
San Jose News
headline read "Gymnast Henrich *Ties* At 22"
Not really
"funny" but I thought we needed something at least vaguely
amusing
to bighten up
our mailboxes. Rather ironic considering her '89 Bars finish
(no way Silivas deserved a 10.0 for
that ... nice Stalders do not a routine
make)
Susan
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 1994 19:49:27 -0500 (CDT)
From: <***@owlnet.rice.edu>
Subject:
Henrich's funeral
Notes on Henrich's funeral, from an AP wire story:
-It was
at St. Mary's Catholic Church today (Friday, 7/29/94). About
250 people attended.
-Joseph
Moreno, her fiance of four years: "Besides being
a gymnast,
Christy was an artist, a decorator and a wonderful cook,
although her
favorite hobby was shopping. Despite
everything you have heard, please
believe that she
loved life, she loved living... Please remember the
wonderful
person that she was, not the disease that took her away."
-More
Moreno, about Christy's parents "Know this -- Sandy and Paul
loved and cherished their daughter. They did everything they could
for her."
-Some lyrics from "I Believe in
You," a song he wrote for Henrich last
year when she appeared to be beating the eating disordrees.
A
product of our country
Pushed
too far
You've
got to be Extra-Tough, little lady,
Now
look this way and grin.
Remember
to hold your head up high,
And
hold the pain within;
Survival on desire
Until it did you in.
So
much regret;
After
all we've been through,
I
still believe in you.
The Rev. Chuck Tobin, a family friend, said the
diseases were "a
raging fire that seemed to
control not only her body, but to take over
her
very person." He also said she
was: "number one as a woman, a
daughter, a fiancee and a friend... This disease can nibble at the
heart of the family.
You can always think, `I could have done more, I
could
have been there more.' But you are called to grieve, and then to
stand up and say no to the guilt. You are called to say `I will go
on, I will run the good race, too.'"
Tobin
also said Moreno wrote a letter to President Clinton, who is
visting Independence, Missourri, on Saturday to push health care
reform. The
letter asked Clinton to help Americans fight all
addictions. Tobin: "Will we simply look back
and say `What a shame,
what
a waste?' Why can't we learn about
all the addictions, why can't
we learn from this
family, who has so much to tell us?"
Tobin told Moreno he should
celebrate his "wedding covenant" with
Henrich,
and that "I know the loss is great. But that sickness no
longer has any control over her. ... She can now eat and
drink at the
living banquet."
Henrich was buried after a brief ceremony at St. Mary's
Catholic
Cemetery in Independence.
------------------------------
Date:
Sun, 31 Jul 94 00:02:00 UTC
From: ***@genie.geis.com
Subject: Henrich/Bulimia/etc.
What sad news about Christy Henrich. ( I don't log on often, so I am a
bit
behind the times.) It is a senseless
and tragic death.
I don't believe that Christy Henrich was the
first gymnast to die from
bulemia. I recall that years ago ('76, '80 or
earlier) a gymnast was
supposed to be
demonstrating the new compulsories at the National Symposium,
but instead she was in Los Angeles dying of anorexia/bulemia. I
vaguely
recall that her name was Donna or Diane
???
The
pervasiveness of bulemia in gymnastics is
debatable. When some
artistic judges worked a Rythmic
meet here, we were shocked at the bodies of
those
girls. When we commented on the possiblity of anorexia we were
repelled
with blatant denial and comments about "that is how they have to be
to compete internationally." Some of these girls were shockingly
thin.
I wonder
whether the responsiblity for anorexia/bulemia lies in the
sport or
in the mind-set of the person in the sport. Anorexia/bulemia
is
not just the domain of gymnastics. Recent literature has connected
anorexia/bulemia to depression and
obsessive-compulsive disorder. I
read
recently that a study has shown success in
treating it with Depakote
(generic valproic acid).
Oddly enough, I had seen
this work last fall. A friend who
was being
treated for depression and OCD was also
mildly bulemic.
When the doctor
changed the meds to include
valporic acid, the bulemic
behavior stopped. I
never connected the two until I read this research
study. Tragically, this
information is too late to help Christy Henrich,
but perhaps it will help
someone else. While medicine is not the only solution
for the emotional
problems of anorexia/bulemia, at least it can keep the person alive while
they work it out.
The other factor that cannot
be ignored is the type of coach that is
insensitive
and insulting. Bela
Karolyi is not the only one. I have seen
plenty
of them on the lower levels of gymnastics.
Hopefully, the USAG
educational programs
will have some effect. Otherwise it
is entirely up to
the parents to protect their
child from a negative environment.
They have
to share some of the responsiblity for continuing to put their child in an
emotionally dangerous situation. Parents often ask me for
recommendations
for coaches and I often recommend
coaches in their area that will not make
their
child an Olympian, but will make her feel like one. That seems a lot
more important to me. But, I am still amazed that some
parents will keep
their child with an abusive
coach (and not a very good coach at that!)
rather
than move them to a different club or change sports.
Kathleen
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 94 22:39:37 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Jennie
Thompson
Kathy Johnson made a good point in regards to the US
Gymnastics 'community'
putting excessive
expectations on Jennie Thompson.
'94 and '95 *should* be learning years for Jennie. Perhaps it is even better
for her not to get too much attention yet.
Shannon
Miller is a good example. Up
through the '91 Nationals, she was
known for high
difficulty but major consistency problems.
IMHO, being in the
'91 Worlds made the difference. Supposedly, the same is true of
Daniela
Silivas at '85 Worlds.
Btw, THANK YOU TBS!!!! (for actually
showing the 'other group')
Mara
------------------------------
Date:
Thu, 28 Jul 94 21:43:38 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Karolyi On Henrich
Via
the AP wires and Jim Litke's column ...
Note:
I found this the exact sort of thing that gives the public the wrong
idea about gymanstics in general.
Youth athletes does not equal evil
dictators in
sport ... though they do obviously occur. These gymnasts are not
"normal" kids in any sense of the world. They are - for
the most part -
driven and insanely singular mided
little girls. This article says what
we've all
heard before "that coaches pressure kids to be champions" While
I
have no doubt that some coaches push kids to
hard the champions we see want
it *BAD* ... their
reasons may not be all that mentally sound but they do
want
it. You can not "force" someone into
greatness. End of
sermon.
Susan
PS-I hope Karoyli chokes on his own BS!
PPS- I have removed
the much re-hashed and rather gory details of Christy's
demise.
-They
perform at the Olympics every four years: wisps of girls, smaller than
the apparatus they work on, trying always to be smaller
still. What happens
to them in between the Games
is often ignored. For most of the
last
half-dozen years of her life, gymnast Christy
Henrich was one of those girls.
Away from the
spotlight her life became a spiraling descent, a desperate
quest to disappear.
-On Tuesday, two years
removed from top-flight competition but still beset by
the
twin demons of anorexia nervosa and bulimia -- starvation and vomiting
whatever food is eaten -- Henrich
succeeded in the saddest way imaginable.
-Two years ago, the U.S.
women's team averaged 16 years old and 83 pounds.
During that same span,
the TV audience that gymnastics pulls in has swelled
in
inverse proportion. If we demand age limits on competition, we'll get
them. It's not enough simply to blame an athlete's parents
or coaches or
agents, or even a sport's
administrators for allowing kids to get hurt -- or
worse
-- providing entertainment for a grownup audience. After all, they are
only taking their cues from the rest of us.
-Whatever
else it has done, Henrich's death has thrown into
stark relief once
more the paradox we have allowed
women's sports like gymnastics and figure
skating
to become: pressure-packed enterprises driven by huge dollars and an
insatiable appetite for younger, smaller, cuter competitors
to chew up and
spit out.
- [Karolyi] "My immediate reaction is that it's
a personal tragedy, a social
tragedy, a tragedy
for our sport, but not the first one,"
- [Karolyi
again] "Who is to blame? I do not want to point my finger
specifically, because in this case there is a victim.
"Instead I will ask:
Who is it drives these girls so, that turns them
into tools in order to
collect such rewards? What
kind of society tells girls they must be skinny to
the
point of craziness, then pushes these weight-loss programs to cheat
people and push them into such a frenzy? "Who is
it," he asked, "that creates
the
Jennifer Capriatis and the others who run away from
sport and turn into
monsters while they are still
young girls?"
-Karolyi said society as a whole should take some of the blame for Henrich's
death.
- Karolyi excluded himself from the long list of suspects.
However, stories
abound about how Karolyi would taunt pupils about being fat, about how
some
of the girls at his academy sensed their
usefulness ended at about the same
time their
figures began to ripen.
-Too
conveniently, perhaps, Karolyi appears to have
excluded himself from the
long list of suspects in
this instance. Certainly, he and his peers are not
blameless.
- But it's not just the coaches, judges
and other officials that athletes
are under
pressure to please. It is the rest of us who demand to be dazzled
by ever-tighter, ever-more reckless circles, somersaults,
jumps and spins.
The rest of us who prize precociousness and femininity in
increasingly
smaller packages that can be neatly
tied off with ribbons and smiles spanned
by braces.
- [More Bela]
"I have believed for a long time that there is an optimal age
for these girls, but it is not the same for all of them, Of
course, a small
body performs some maneuvers
easier than a taller one. But it's a natural
phenomenon
that strength and grace should increase with age, also.
- [Karolyi]"In
my own experience, two of the best students I ever had, Mary
Lou Retton and Nadia Comaneci, had to go through puberty and it
made a very
specific mark of time on their bodies.
But they kept their weight [Nadia's
weight
"steady"???? ... this is about as accurate
as his autobio] and their
temperament
steady. That shows me it is not always a problem to be in top
form. And so, myself, I would not discourage anybody, no
matter what is
involved, from seeking their
opportunity."
------------------------------
Date: Sat, 30 Jul 94
21:09:46 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: List of AA & EF
Qualifiers???
Does anyone have a list of AA and/or EF qualifiers?
Mara
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 94 19:53:44 BST
From: ***@ic.ac.uk
Subject: Michelle Campi
> Two 1992 Olympic gymnastic
medalists, Dominique Dawes and Michelle Campi
>
[huh?], will be joined by 120 of the nation's top
female gymnasts in
> competition for the
national title.
Ha. As far
as I know, Michelle Campi returned to the gym to
'train' for
the first time last week since the
accident. She said she did a glide kip
on her
first day back, and logically she's going to take things slowly to
ease back into the swing of things. She said her back was
sore but was
holding up well.
Sherwin
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 1994 05:56:35 -0700
From: <***@pollux.usc.edu>
Subject:
More Henrich Info (from the Chicago Tribune)
Susan
posts:
----
-U.S. Olympian Cathy Rigby twice went into cardiac
arrest. Christy Phillips
slit her wrists in a
failed suicide attempt. Olympians Cathy Johnson, Nadia
Comaneci and former Bela Karolyi student Erica Stokes
have all battled the
disease.
====
Is
it a female problem? Have there been (famous atheles
or otherwise)
males with Anorexia? There must be
but perhaps it predominantly
afflicts women
compared to men.
Anil.
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 94 14:12:52 BST
From: ***@axion.bt.co.uk
Subject: More Henrich Info (from the Chicago Tribune)
>Is it
a female problem? Have there been (famous
atheles or otherwise)
>males
with Anorexia? There must be but perhaps it predominantly
>afflicts women compared to men.
Surprisingly
enough Dennis Quaid (the famous actor) admitted
the
other day he had sufferred from Anorexia. He had
decided
to lose some weight for his part in the
film 'Wyatt Earp'
but he still thought he was too
fat and he just kept
losing weight.
Eventually
he realised that he weighed less than he did
when he was a teenager and so he began putting on weight
again.
Clive
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 94 21:27:50 PDT
From: ***@eworld.com
Subject: More Info on Henrich
Why is it that Karolyi's
comments in rachele's last post remind one eerily
of
some soviet spin-doctor explaining that the
USSR's invasion of Afganistan was
a tragedy, but one brought upon not by the invader, but by
the world
situation as a whole?
On advice
of my attorney, I will leave it at that.
David
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 94 02:49:12 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Non-Goodwill Gym
On TV
ESPN is replaying it's coverage of the
Peachtree Club Int'l Invite that took
palce
Feb. 11 '94 in Atlanta. It airs on Tuesday (the 2nd. of Aug.) at 1 AM
PDT.
Susan
Hmm... as I type this it's 10 AM in
St. Petersburg and the women's team comp.
is
getting under way. The fact that I know this doesn't mean that I'm
obssessed does it. Nah ...
couldn't be ;-)
------------------------------
Date: Sat, 30
Jul 94 17:19:38 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Proposed NCAA Women's
Changes
To All:
It had been asked what the other regional sites are for the 1995
Women's
NCAA gymnastics season. They are
University of Michigan, University of
Nebraska, Towson
State and Oregon Sate. The Northeast regional site has not
yet been chosen.
--- Ronald
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 1994 14:36:50 -0500 (CDT)
From: <***@owlnet.rice.edu>
Subject:
Results: GG, Women's team
>From the AP wire, the results of the
Women's Team Competition at the
Goodwill Games:
Team
1, Russia (Oksana Fabrichnova, Yelena Grosheva,
Dina Kochetkova, Svetlana
Khorkina), 117.375 points.
2, Romania (Ionela
Loaies, Andreea Cacovean, Angela Ghimpu, Ana Mariya
Bikan), 116.000.
3, Ukraine (Tatyana Malaya, Irina Bulakhova,
Oksana Knizhnik, Liliya
Podkopyeva),
115.650.
4,
United States (Marianna Webster, Joplin, Mo.; Soni Meduna, Colon, Mo.;
Jennie Thompson,
Wichita Falls, Texas; Shannon Miller, Edmund, Okla.), 115.375.
5, China (Fun Dinli, Chzhan Li, Lo Li, Din Yui), 112.650.
6, Spain (Veronica Castro, Elisabet Romero, Mercedes Pacheco, Monica
Martin),
111.275.
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 94 23:27:36 EDT
From: <***@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu>
Subject:
TBS coverage
Well it certainly was better than ABC's!! (But I guess that isn't too
hard
to accomplish...). It was funny, it almost
seemed as if they'd read the gymn
posts - suddenly we started to hear the names of vaults, and
lo and behold,
there were the Romanians, the
Chinese, the Spanish and the individuals (true,
not
the most thorough coverage of them, but at least we SAW them). And I was
very pleased to see that someone from TBS managed to find an
announcer who
pronounced the Russians' names
right :). It was during the little "up close and
personal"
piece on the Russian girls. He got EVERY name right!! Now, Bart and
Kathy,
why weren't you listening? For that matter, I found it very amusing
after Knizhnik's bar routine, you
can very clearly hear the Russian announcer
introducing
Dina Kochetkova on vault (and obviously pronouncing
her name
correctly), and 3 seconds later either
Kathy or Bart pronounced it wrong! Can't
they hear
the announcer in the arena? I really don't think you need to know
Russian to be able to pick out the names. I mean, I don't
speak any Japanese,
but when I watch tapes from
Japanese TV I can pick out the names. Oh well...
It's too bad they cut
away from Kuznetsova's beam; I would have loved to
see a
replay of that cool move she did (and a
score would have been nice too...) But,
then, I
wonder who has control of the camera and what routines are shown?
Anyway,
though it had its flaws, TBS's coverage beats ABC's by a MILE. I was
very happy they showed all the Russian girls on floor, and 2
of the 3 Romanians
who did floor. I am rather
mystified by Shannon's score, though. Now I AM a fan
of
hers and really like to see her do well, but I don't quite understand how
she could outscore the Russians, especially Khorkina, when her tumbling was
nowhere
near as difficult. If this meet were being held in the US, I'd get it,
but this is happening in RUSSIA! Very odd...
Since you've all
probably gathered I have an obsession with Russian names,
I thought I'd
pass on what some of them actually mean. "Knizhnik"
means a
Biblical scribe or a lover of books (it comes
from the word "kniga" = "book").
"Fabrichnova" comes from "fabrika"
= "factory," or the adjective "fabrichny,"
meaning "factory-made" or "having to do with
a factory," or (as a noun)
"factory
worker." "Grosheva" I assume comes
from "grosh," which means "half aa
kopek,"
"penny" or "farthing," - basically something not worth
much. Not too
appropriate for Elena, that's for
sure! "Podkopayeva" I am guessing comes
from
the verb "podkopat,"
which means "to sap" or "to undermine." "Malaya"
is the
adjective "small" - well, that
one seems to fit okay! A "kochet" is a
"rooster," but I don't know for sure if
that's the source of the name
"Kochetkova,"
but it seems plausible. The other names (Khorkina, Bulakhova), I
don't know the
source of. Anyway, I found some of these slightly amusing, so
just thought I'd pass them along. They aren't quite as funny
as "Gorbachev,"
which means
"hunchback," or "Khrushchev," which is "a large
European beetle."
What names for the USSR's former leaders to have!
But my all-time favorite
Russian surname has to be "Vnebrakov," which means, literally,
"out-of-wedlock." How'd you like to be saddled with a
name like that! (I don't
know of any gymnasts
with that name, but there is a Russian politician named
that
- I can imagine the jokes during his election campaign!) Well, that's it
for the Russian trivia. If any of the men competitors have
funny names, I'll
post them later this week.
Anyone know why Chusovitina is competing
and Galieva isn't? Or why Belarus
didn't send a full team? (They had one in Brisbane.) Just curious.
Beth
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 30 Jul 94 12:34:41 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: UNIVISION
broadcasts before ABC
On the west coast, at least, Univision will be
broadcasting the Goodwill
gymnastics an hour
before ABC will. It will be
broadcast in Spanish, of
course (according to TV
Host, an unreliable source)
:).
La viga de equilibrio
es ancho cuatro pulgada: Translation: the beam is
four
inches wide :> (Well, it's close, anyway. I don't really know much
Spanish.)
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 94 02:03:32 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: US Goodwill
Games TV Schedule
Remember all times are EDT ...
SATURDAY,
JULY 30 - TBS, 12:05 AM: Boxing Finals; Track and field: Men's and
Women's
Relays, Men's Triple Jump, Decathlon; Wrestling Finals; Gymnastics
Preview
SATURDAY,
JULY 30 - ABC, 3:30 PM: Triathlon; Women's Gymnastics, Team
Competition;
Boxing Finals; Wrestling Finals; Women's Volleyball, USA Game
SATURDAY,
JULY 30 - TBS, 8:05 PM: Triathlon; Women's Gymnastics, Team
Competition;
Boxing Finals; Wrestling Finals; Women's Volleyball, USA Game
SUNDAY,
JULY 31 - TBS, 12:05 AM: Triathlon; Women's Gymnastics, Team
Competition;
Boxing Finals; Wrestling Finals; Women's Volleyball, USA Game
SUNDAY,
JULY 31 - ABC, 2:30 PM: Men's Team Cycling; Women's Gymnastics,
All-Around
Competition; Women's Volleyball, USA Game; Wrestling, Bruce
Baumgartner
SUNDAY,
JULY 31 - TBS, 9:05 PM: Men's Team Cycling; Women's Gymnastics,
All-Around
Competition; Women's Volleyball, USA Game; Wrestling, Bruce
Baumgartner
MONDAY,
AUGUST 1 - TBS, 12:05 AM: Men's Team Cycling; Women's Gymnastics,
All-Around
Competition; Women's Volleyball, USA Game; Wrestling, Bruce
Baumgartner
MONDAY,
AUGUST 1 - TBS, 8:05 PM: Women's Gymnastics Finals; Women's
Volleyball, USA
Game; Women's Cycling; Synchronized Swimming Finals
TUESDAY, AUGUST 2
- TBS, 12:05 AM: Women's Gymnastics Finals; Women's
Volleyball, USA Game;
Women's Cycling; Synchronized Swimming Finals
TUESDAY, AUGUST 2 - TBS,
8:05 PM: Women's Three-Meter Springboard Diving
Competition; Men's Gymnastics,
All-Around Competition; Short Track
Speedskating
WEDNESDAY,
AUGUST 3 - TBS, 12:05 AM: Women's Three-Meter Springboard
Diving
Competition; Men's Gymnastics, All-Around Competition; Short Track
Speedskating
WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 3 - TBS, 8:05 PM:
Men's Gymnastics, All-Around
Competition; Men's Pairs and Technical Figure
Skating; Women's Volleyball
Semifinals; Figure Skating, Ice Dancing
Compulsories
THURSDAY, AUGUST 4 - TBS, 12:05 AM: Men's Gymnastics,
All-Around
Competition; Men's Pairs and Technical Figure Skating; Women's
Volleyball
Semifinals; Figure Skating, Ice Dancing Compulsories
THURSDAY,
AUGUST 4 - TBS, 8:05 PM: Men's Gymnastic Finals; Men's One-Meter
Springboard
Diving; Figure Skating, Women's Technical Program, Ice Dancing
Original
Program
FRIDAY, AUGUST 5 - TBS, 12:05 AM: Men's Gymnastic Finals;
Men's One-Meter
Springboard Diving; Figure Skating, Women's Technical
Program, Ice Dancing
Original Program
FRIDAY, AUGUST 5 - TBS, 8:05
PM: Figure Skating Pairs Competition; Men's
Gymnastics Apparatus Finals;
Men's Three-Meter Springboard Diving; Woman's
Volleyball, Gold Medal
Match
SATURDAY, AUGUST 6 - TBS, 12:05 AM: Figure Skating Pairs
Competition; Men's
Gymnastics Apparatus Finals; Men's Three-Meter
Springboard Diving; Woman's
Volleyball, Gold Medal Match
SATURDAY,
AUGUST 6 - ABC, 4:30 PM: Women's Figure Skating Free Program;
Gymnastics
Mixed-Team Apparatus Competition; Women's One-Meter Springboard
and 10M Platform Diving Competition; Women's Basketball
Semifinals; Rowing
SATURDAY, AUGUST 6 - TBS, 8:05 PM: Women's Figure
Skating Free Program;
Gymnastics Mixed-Team Apparatus Competition; Women's
One-Meter Springboard
and 10M Platform Diving
Competition; Women's Basketball Semifinals; Rowing
SUNDAY, AUGUST 7 -
TBS, 12:05 AM: Women's Figure Skating Free Program;
Gymnastics Mixed-Team
Apparatus Competition; Women's One-Meter Springboard
and
10M Platform Diving Competition; Women's Basketball Semifinals; Rowing
SUNDAY,
AUGUST 7 - ABC, 1:30 PM: Men's 10-Meter Platform Diving Finals;
Figure Skating
Champions Exhibition; Gymnastics Mixed-Team Finals; Soccer;
Ice
Dancing
Finals; Women's Basketball, Gold Medal Match; Rowing; Closing
Ceremonies
SUNDAY,
AUGUST 7 - TBS, 8:05 PM: Men's 10-Meter Platform Diving Finals;
Figure
Skating
Champions Exhibition; Gymnastics Mixed-Team Finals; Soccer; Ice
Dancing
Finals;
Women's Basketball, Gold Medal Match; Rowing; Closing Ceremonies
MONDAY,
AUGUST 7 - TBS, 12:05 AM: Men's 10-Meter Platform Diving Finals;
Figure
Skating Champions Exhibition; Gymnastics Mixed-Team Finals; Soccer;
Ice
Dancing
Finals; Women's Basketball, Gold Medal Match; Rowing; Closing
Ceremonies
-posted by Susan
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 29 Jul 94 02:04:39 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: US Goodwill
Games TV Schedule
Oops and one more ...
FRIDAY, JULY 29 -
TBS, 8:05 PM: Boxing Finals; Track and field: Men's and
Women's Relays,
Men's Triple Jump, Decathlon; Wrestling Finals; Gymnastics
Preview
-posted by Susan
------------------------------
End
of gymn Digest
******************************