gymn
Digest
Thu, 1 Dec 94 Volume 3 :
Issue 42
Today's
Topics:
*DORTMOND VIDEOS FOR SALE*
...
Address request for Nissen
Australia and World's
Dortmond worlds
report #1 (2 msgs)
Dortmond Worlds Report #2 (3 msgs)
Dortmund - US Women
Dortmund - Women's Finals (2 msgs)
Dortmund questions
Gogean
Gymnast Address
JPEG Site Address Change
Men's NCAA
request for help...
Romanian Juniors Info
Soviet forced pregnancy accusation (3 msgs)
Worlds (3 msgs)
This is a digest of
the gymn@athena.mit.edu mailing list.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 25 Nov 94 7:52:43 18000
From: ***@freenet.scri.fsu.edu
Subject:
*DORTMOND VIDEOS FOR SALE*
I brought my camcorder along with me to Dortmond and was once again
able
to tape 8 or 9 hours of gymnastics.I need to make
some extra
money to pay for gym expenses for
winter nationals(if I qualify) and
this was the
easiest way .I was extremely pleased.
with the way
they turned out.I also included some partial sets in
the
video.I guess it's
better to see some of the routine than none at
all.I'm not even sure that the meet will be televised.I usually concentrated
on
2 teams during each session,but usually was able to
get a few of
the gymnast from the other rotations.Below are the sessions and prices.
MEN'S
TEAM PRELIMS-$30 (two tapes)
WOMEN'S TEAM PRELIMS-$30 (two tapes)
MEN'S
TEAM FINALS-$15 (one tape)
WOMEN'S TEAM FINALS-$15 (one tape)
Also
add $2 PER session for shipping and handling.I'll
be sending the
videos priority mail.
If
you have any questions,don't
hesitate to drop me a line.I've got a
Winter
National qualifier here in Tallahassee next weekend,so I can
answer your ?'s then.If you want to order now my
NEW address is:
Billy
Talk to you soon,
Billy
-
------------------------------
Date:
Wed, 23 Nov 94 10:44 PST
From: ***@MVS.OAC.UCLA.EDU
Subject: ...
underrated forgotten gymnast of the week: Irina Baraksanova
------------------------------
Date:
Mon, 21 Nov 1994 17:35:53 -0500
From: ***@isscad.com
Subject: Address
request for Nissen
One of or local schools has give my gym a set of Nissen men's parallel bars.
They are in excellent condition,
with the exception that the spin locks are
missing.
Can someone provide me with an address or telephone # for which I may
contact
the manufacturer. We are in a startup phase, and I have not had a lot of
experience
in ordering gymnastics equipment.
Thanks
in advance for any help.
Gene
------------------------------
Date: Mon, 28 Nov 1994
09:13:08 +1000
From: ***@pharm.med.upenn.edu
Subject: Australia and
World's
I had the opportunity to stay in the same hotel with the
Australian coaches
and the Great Britian gymnastics teams, so ...
Regarding the
Australia situation, they have plenty of women and men for a
world championship team, and had one put together. The coach for the men's
was explaining to me that he and the women's coach came to
world's to
discuss the selection process for
getting into the championships.
Because this was a team event only they selected the teams
from how they
placed their regional
championships. Australia is not a
part of any of the
regional championships, and
thus did not have an opportunity to qualify.
Mayland
------------------------------
Date:
Thu, 24 Nov 94 20:25:09 EST
From: ***@freenet.scri.fsu.edu
Subject: Dortmond worlds report #1
Hello
all.I got back from Dortmond on Monday completely exhausted.I
made it back home for Thanksgiving,so
I thought I would write a short report.
It will be my usual rambling,so please bear with me.
-Andrea Molnar tore
her acl on floor while performing a triple
full.Also a male french gymnast broke his kneecap on vault.
-Dominique
looked fantastic and added a HIGH free hip reverse hect
on
bars.She left out two
layouts on beam in prelims but other than that hit
everything.
-Shannon
only did compulsories.Everything
went smoothly until bars.She
was
attempting the toe on front half dismount,but didn't
get her feet on the
bar.She
took an extra swing and giant then did the dismount cleanly.When
her score was flashed(9.6 something or other) the crowd booed quite loudly and
it went onfor about five minutes.
-Amy Chow
fell 7 times in prelims,but
recouped and hit all her
routines in finals.JC phelps did a fantastic
job hitting ALL of her routines.Larissa fell on comp
bars(her free hip turned into a free hip geinger!)
and was shakey on optional beam both days.
-The
romanians were the clear and deserving winners.Russia watered
down their sets and also had to count a fall on beam.Perhaps the results might have been different had Svetlanta Ivanova not been injured.The US had a few minor breaks,but
no falls and finished 2nd.Ukraine and Belarus lacked depth which prevented them
from medaling.China was great on bars and beam,but a little weak on the other apparatus.Mo
looked great and scored 9.9 on floor in finals.
-There weren't too
many new skills with the exception of a full
twisting
reverse hect to a geinger.Kinda
ugly,but exciting nonetheless.
-Ezster Ovary came out of retirement and competed for Hungary.She had
a few breaks,but was in much better shape than she was
before.
-The american men did better than
they had done atprevious worlds,but
still only finished
9th.Kip Simons compulsory rings were SUPER!
more
later if I'm not asleep.
Billy
--
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 26 Nov 1994 16:38:03 -0500 (EST)
From: ***@minerva.cis.yale.edu
Subject:
Dortmond worlds report
#1
> -Dominique looked fantastic and added a HIGH free hip reverse hect on
> bars.She
le
Trivia: a free hip reverse hecht
is called a "Hindorff" after the east
German
(Silvia her first name?) and is an "E".
> s and also had to count a fall on beam.Perhaps
the results might have
> been differ
> ent had Svetlanta
Ivanova not been injured.
Of course, then
you'd have to factor in what might have happened had
Miller competed
too.
> -There weren't too many new skills with the exception
of a full > twisting reverse
> hect to a geinger.Kinda
ugly,but exciting nonetheless.
Was this in
women's? (i.e. a Shushunova
to Gienger?)
> -Ezster
Ovary came out of retirement and competed for Hungary.She
had
> a few break
> s,but was in much better shape than she was
before.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Maybe there *is* hope for Zmeskal
and Boginskaya.
:)
Adriana
------------------------------
Date:
Fri, 25 Nov 94 10:01:37 18000
From: ***@freenet.scri.fsu.edu
Subject: Dortmond Worlds Report #2
Before I leave for
Kissimmee...
-Scherbo was in the best shape
I've seen since Barcelona.Did the same
sets as in Brisbane,but looked
much sharper.
-Elena Piskun was the best all
around gymnast there(IMHO).She's really
worked on cleaning up her form.She
had a fall on beam(flip flop
full) and changed her
passes on floor(whip through to triple full,two
and one half twist punch front layout,piked
full in.)Nailed her vaults
and was undercored.
-Nadia and Bart are engaged.They both sat in front of me
at the
competition.Very
nice people.
-I had an interesting run in with one of the US men's
team members.He
asked me if I was going to write another article for IG.I
said
probably not and asked if he liked my last one.He then said "No,it
was
pretty bad" in a very hostile way.I later found out that he told
someone
that the all arounders did very well at Brisbane and
I
"trashed" them in my article.Wrong on BOTH counts!(John fell
twice,Chainey once,Mihai
three,and I lost count with Scott.Did
anyone
else out there think that I trashed
them?)I'll get over the
hurt somehow...
-The
chinese men did extremely well and deserved the gold.Li Jing
showed up and was used pretty early in the lineup.
-The
tour was a lot of fun as usual.I
met up with a few
gymners(beth,susan,nancy,and mara.)We
stayed in Amsterdam for 2 and a
half days then
headed over to D0ortmond for the competition.
-Shannon and Steve left
Germany the day after compulsories.
That's all I can think of.More next week.Hope
everyone had a nice
Thanksgiving.
Billy
--
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 26 Nov 94 22:51:00 UTC
From: ***@genie.geis.com
Subject: Dortmond Worlds Report #2
Billy wrote:
>-I had an interesting run in
with one of the US men's team members...he
>told
someone that the all arounders did very well at
Brisbane and I
>"trashed" them in my
article...Did anyone else out there think that I
>trashed
them?
No, Billy didn't
trash the US men. He simply said,
"...the all-arounders
continued
the Americans' post-1984 slump" [which is quite true, IMO]. The
team
member who took offense with that statement should consider this: from
1976 to 1984, the US men won 8
individual Olympic medals, 9 individual World
medals,
an Olympic team gold, and a World team bronze. In contrast, since
1985 they have won
only 1 individual Olympic medal and 1 individual World
medal. In Brisbane, 3 US men qualified for
event finals (which isn't bad),
but one must
remember that 2 of these qualifiers were specialists. Umphrey
was the only AA'er to
qualify. If the US AA'ers had performed "very well"
then why didn't Keswick, Roethlisberger and Bagiu also qualify for EF?
Let's face it, they didn't
perform very well in Brisbane and haven't for the
past
10 years.
Debbie
------------------------------
Date:
Sun, 27 Nov 1994 14:05:33 -0800 (PST)
From: ***@netcom.com
Subject: Dortmond Worlds Report #2
{...}
>
>
-I had an interesting run in with one of the US men's team members.He
> asked me
if I was going to write another article for IG.I said
> probably not and asked if he liked my last one.He then said "No,it
was
> pretty bad" in a very hostile way.I later found out that he told
> someone that the all arounders did
very well at Brisbane and I
> "trashed"
them in my article.Wrong on BOTH counts!(John
fell
> twice,Chainey once,Mihai three,and I lost count
with Scott.Did anyone
> else
out there think that I trashed them?)I'll get over the
> hurt somehow...
Noooooo....
Are
we doing better tyhan we were in 84
?
Nooooo......
Are
we doing the same as 84 ?
Noooooo......
Are we doing worse than 84 ?
Youbetcha !
Should
you take his complaint seriously ?
I DONT think so !
Get over it and write the guy off as
"sour grapes"
Right now USA mens gymn sux bigtime !
Its the truth
and if he cant cope, well its tough tortillas !
So where is your school located ?
-texx
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 26 Nov 1994 15:11:33 -0800 (PST)
From: ***@netcom.com
Subject:
Dortmund - US Women
Here's how the US women did individually in the
team finals. I found it
in the USAG section on Delphi, and am too lazy to add them
up. :)
V
UB
B
FX
Dominique Dawes 9.887 9.825 9.837 9.850
Kerri Strug
9.812 9.675 9.700 9.825
Amanda Borden
9.587 9.725 9.625 9.812
Amy Chow
9.687 9.375 9.712 9.687
Jaycee Phelps
9.650 9.625 9.587 9.637
Larissa Fontaine 9.825 9.662 9.300 9.625
Very
consistent!
Debbie
------------------------------
Date:
Mon, 21 Nov 94 23:42:00 UTC
From: ***@genie.geis.com
Subject: Dortmund
- Women's Finals
>Anybody knows what the Russian team is?
Dina Kochetkova,
Svetlana Khorkina, Oksana Fabrichnova,
Eugenia Roschina,
Elena Grosheva, Natalia Ivanova, &
Elena Lebedeva. The last 3 competed at
this year's Jr. Europeans.
>We need those Gymners who went to Dortmund to tell us the details
quick!
Agreed! Did Eurosport
cover this competition?
Debbie
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 22 Nov 94 10:49:10 GMT
From: ***@ic.ac.uk
Subject: Dortmund -
Women's Finals
> Agreed! Did Eurosport
cover this competition?
Not a sausage. Absolutely no coverage of
Dortmund Worlds in any of
the British TV channels
or European satellite channels. I haven't
seen
anything... I'm hoping for some coverage on the local German
channels that I could get hold of... Don't know if there's
any there...
Sherwin
------------------------------
Date:
Sun, 27 Nov 94 23:28:26 GMT
From: ***@ic.ac.uk
Subject: Dortmund
questions
Thank you so much Beth for all the inside stories at
Dortmund! It was all
very interesting! I like
your descriptions on the Russians! I heard that
the
Romanians, in contrast, were very much to themselves. Did you get to
contact any of them? How about the others such as Piskoun, Podkopayeva,
etc.? And how about the Chinese men, what was their reaction
to winning
the Gold? What were the reactions of
the Romanian girls when the wrong
anthem was
played? Did they look happy winning the team gold? (Did Gina
smile??)
Sorry I've got so many questions...
anybody who feels like answering them
please
do!
Thank you so much.
Sherwin
------------------------------
Date:
Sun, 27 Nov 1994 17:40:08 -0500 (EST)
From: ***@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu
Subject:
Gogean
Sherwin wrote me and
asked about Gogean's fall on beam during the
optionals portion of the
qualifying. She was going for her layout series and as
her
foot landed on the first layout, it slipped off the beam and she fell
backward, hitting her back and her head HARD on the beam.
She fell off, quite
dazed, and I thought she
might even have a concussion. But she got back up, did
a
leap or something, and then Octavian Belu just yelled
at her to get down. The
Romanians didn't need her score to stay in the
lead, and I figure he wanted to
make sure she was
okay. She scored a 7-something, which was a bit ridiculous,
since she only did about a third of her routine. As Susan
put it, the judges
must have been marking her out
of a 21! But the score was dropped anyway, and
Gina seemed to be fine. She
went ahead to compete floor and nailed everything.
Hategan
had an ankle sprain early in the week and did not do compulsories.
I
thought she was out for the entire competition, but she DID do optionals (she
ended up
anchoring on beam because of Gina's fall).
Sherwin also asked why
some of the better Romanians were not on the team.
The story I heard was
that it was a political thing: the team had to include at
least one (maybe more?) girl(s) from the Bucharest team; it
couldn't be all
Deva girls.
I forgot to mention
this in my other post. Even though the Romanians were
favored
to win, the meet organizers seemed unprepared for this and played the
wrong Romanian anthem during the award ceremony! I think it
was one of the old
communist ones. After some
confusion, someone found a tape of the correct
anthem,
and the award ceremony was repeated. This more or less epitomizes how
well the meet was organized! (Another problem was that the
organizers printed
the tickets and then remodeled
the arena, so many people - myself included -
ended
up with nonexistent seats! Naturally, there were no ushers the first few
days to sort this out, so people basically sat wherever they
wanted!).
Someone else wrote and asked about Kerri Strug.
She performed well, but
was a bit tentative on
bars. In optional qualifying she also scooted out of
bounds
on floor, since she landed rather stiff-legged. But she was very solid
in finals, and she got a 9.8-something on floor. I still
don't think that
routine suits her, but I guess
the judges disagreed.
I know Billy mentioned
Shannon's compulsory bars and how her foot slipped
off
the bar as she was going for her dismount. If I remember right, she got a
9.525,
which many people I've talked to said is impossible.
The deduction
should have been between .5 and .9.
As Billy said, the whole arena booed for
about
five minutes. In a press release issued later, Steve Nunno
said only the
Russians were booing! The only Russians I saw in the arena
at that time were
the women's team, but even if
the entire delegation had been there, they
couldn't
have made that much noise! I think the crowd was predominantly German.
Anyway,
the score created such a furor that there was an entire press
conference on it the next day. Jackie Fie said the judges
took the mandatory .3
for an extra swing and that
was it. In my opinion, it was just another case of
blatant
cheating (certainly not Shannon's fault; I feel bad for her). There
were other impossible scores in the meet (Gina's beam, for
example), but this
one attracted the most
attention.
Someone (Sherwin?) asked about Fabrichnova. I
think she might have had
some sort of ankle
injury. They announced her on floor in optionals
qualifying,
but she didn't compete. The Russians
were going to qualify anyway, so I think
Arkaev
was resting her. She DID do floor in finals, but I don't remember too
much of the routine since I was trying to take pictures of
her. I just remember
that I didn't care for it too
much. She is such a pretty gymnast, and a
classical
routine would suit her much better, in my opinion. She seems to be a
happy girl, and was always extremely friendly and full of
smiles whenever we
saw her. She and Dina were
always together; Dina seemed a lot more shy and
reserved
than Oksana, but was also very nice. I don't remember seeing her smile
much though. Grosheva is quite a
character. She was a little social butterfly
during
the banquet, and she reminded me of Shushunova in
terms of sense of
humor. I was taking a picture
of her and Misyutin, and she took his beer away
and hid it behind her back. It was really cute. Khorkina is also really nice,
and
was quite a chatterbox when John Crumlish interviewed
her. She said she was
too fat (!) in Brisbane and
had tried very hard to slim down for Dortmund. As
she
was saying this, she slid her hand along her hip and thigh and struck a
model-type pose. She also said one of her favorite hobbies
is eating. As for
her new hairstyle, she said she
just wanted a change. She seems very modest. A
girl
on the tour told her she was pretty, and she sort of rolled her eyes and
shook her head, saying she wasn't satisfied with her looks
at all.
A
bit of gossip: Lyudmila Stobchataya (who was not
there) is dating
Vladimir Shamenko of the
Ukrainian men's team. A German photographer told me
they
were married, but when I asked Rustam Sharipov about this, he burst out
laughing
and said that they were just dating. He also confirmed that Lysenko
and Kalinina have retired but DO
want to come to the States for college.
Lyudmila is still working out, but
mainly to be with Shamenko.
I gues
I've strayed from my topic of "Gogean," but
I keep remembering more
things. Belenky is a really funny guy. Literally every time we saw
him he said
he was tired and/or hungry. He gave
us a really nice interview, telling us,
among
other things, that he has used some of his money to buy apartments in
Vladimir,
Russia for his mother, older sister and grandparents. He did this
because Vladimir is a safe place, whereas Baku is basically
a war zone, and he
wanted his family to be safe.
In response to a question, he denied that any of
his
relatives is a rabbi. He was able to get German citizenship so quickly
because his grandfather is German.
By contrast, when we
asked Shcherbo if he helped out his Belarusian
teammates financially, he got a bit indignant and said,
"of course not, why
should I?" Aside
from that comment, he was very pleasant and even refused to
accept our compliment that he looked in great shape!
More later, if I
remember anything else or if anyone has specific
questions.
:)
Beth
------------------------------
Date: Tue, 22
Nov 94 20:20:49 PST
From: ***@hicap.seanet.com
Subject: Gymnast
Address
Could you please forward this to the gymn
list. I'm
not sure of the address.
-----------------------------------
Gymn-list
My name is Michelle. I am 13 years old and train at Puget
Sound
School of Gymnastics. I am training to qualify as an elite
gymnast this
year.
I have a problem that someone
might be able to help me with. I
have a
school project where I am to write to
someone famous, from another
country. I want to write to Lila Potcopieva (something like that).
Can anyone help
me find the address. I would like to know the correct
spelling of her name, the country she competes for (Ukraine,
I think)
and hopfully
an address or someway to contact her by mail. This is
very
important to me and I'm not sure where to start. Plus the project
is
due to be completed soon.
Thank you very much.
------------------------------
Date:
Wed, 23 Nov 1994 17:05:34 -0800 (PST)
From: ***@netcom.com
Subject:
JPEG Site Address Change
Beginning tomorrow, Nov. 24, the gymnastics
JPEGs and GIFs will be
located at:
ftp.netcom.com in pub/ta/talloo/gifs
^^
and will revert back to the current
subdirectory (pub/talloo/gifs) on
Dec 26.
Debbie
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 22 Nov 1994 13:19:20 -0500 (EST)
From: ***@tiger.hsc.edu
Subject:
Men's NCAA
This is a general letter to the group:
Does anyone
have any information concerning the status of Men's NCAA
Div I
gymnastics? D II,III, club tems have their own
nationals, but
they are not NCAA sponsored.
Ron? Anyone? The gymnastics club at the U of Chicago
is vitally interested.
We know women's gymnastics will not likely be
dropped at any collegiate level
(though individual
schools ARE dropping programs.)
Sincerely,
Julius
P.S. See everyone after Thanksgiving (no net
access).
------------------------------
Date: Fri, 25 Nov
1994 18:57:57 PST
From: ***@electriciti.com
Subject: request for
help...
Hello,
Long time no see.
I shipped along the
Ukraine Federation address for Michelle. For anyone
else
who's interested, it's:
Ukrainian Gymnastics Federation
42 Esplanadna Street
252023 Kiev
UKRAINE
If
you need other addresses, you can get a printed sheet from the Hall of
Fame
(if you wanna tangle with Susan <g>) or IG, or
just email me. I
usually have the file
around.
I'd add to Billy's posts about worlds, but he pretty much hit
the main
points. Coverage will be in January and
February IG issues.
Later,
Nancy
------------------------------
Date:
Thu, 24 Nov 94 11:32:27 GMT
From: ***@ic.ac.uk
Subject: Romanian
Juniors Info
Here's some info about some of the top Romanian
Juniors:
Corina Ungureanu b. 29th Aug 1980 1.38m 29kg
Mirela Tugurlan b. 4th Apr 1980 1.36m 28kg
Claudia Presacan b. 28th Dec 1979 1.41m 30kg
Monica Zahiu
b. 3rd Nov 1982 1.40m 29kg
Alexandra Marinescu b. (13 years old) 1.38m 28kg
Aurelia
Gheba
b. 20th Oct 1981
1.34m 27kg
Camelia Andronic b. 22nd Oct 1980 1.37m 28kg
Sorry I haven't got the
most important bit of info (Marinescu's
birthday).
Those weights are so similar!
Sherwin
------------------------------
Date:
Sat, 26 Nov 1994 13:43:57 GMT
From: ***@achilles.demon.co.uk
Subject:
Soviet forced pregnancy accusation
I'm probably twenty-four hours
behind the field in picking this news
item up, but
just in case it hasn't crossed the Atlantic yet, I thought
I'd pass on the
following report in today's (saturday) Daily
Telegraph
(London).
"...The world of gymnastics has been
taken aback by the accusations of
a competitor
from the former Soviet Union that she was forced by coaches
to become pregnant then have an abortion as an alternative
to taking
performance-enhancing drugs.
Olga Kovalenko, who under her maiden name Karaseva
was a team gold
medallist
at the 1968 Mexico Olympics, said on German television: "The
doctors told us the body of a pregnant woman produced more
male hormones
and could therefore become
stronger."
Kovalenko, now 44, broke down as
she said she became pregnant by her boyfriend
and
had an abortion after 10 weeks. "If I had refused I would not have
been allowed to go to the games."
First hints of
benefits to be gained from pregnancy came at the 1956 Melbourne
Games when
it emerged that 10 of 26 Soviet women medallists were
pregnant..."
This isn't the first time I've heard this
suggestion. The BBC series "More
Than A Game" broadcast it a year
or so back, though without a specific
connection
to gymnastics. The following thoughts occur to me:
i)
It's no use anyone trying to pretend this didn't
happen. Not any more.
You do not go on tv and make that kind of allegation if it isn't
true.
ii) Now the dam's broken, there'll probably be quite a bit more
to come.
The fact is that, as a system, Soviet sport didn't give a damn for
its
individual competitors. I'm sure many - and I
hope most - coaches on the
ground had a different
attitude. But they didn't set policy. If you want
confirmation
of the attitudes of those who did, check out Olga Korbut's
biography where she says how the winners of meets
were known in advance.
iii) Despite the above, I'm still dubious
forced pregnancies would have
been much help in
gymnastics. Indeed, considering how average ages and body
sizes have come down since '68, I doubt they've been a
realistic possibility
for the last decade and a
half. Of course, this raises the question of what
else
may have been going on. Anabolics? Unlikely:
"heavy" muscles are wrong
for the sport.
Testosterone? Maybe.
iv) I also think (hope?) the use of forced
pregnancies may have died out
pretty quickly
because neither Olga Korbut (in her "I despise
everybody"
autobio)
or Elena Mukhina (who dumped hard on her coach in
"More Than A
Game") or Elena Shushunova
(who, I gather, also attacked the system a while
back)
mentioned anything about it. Given how candid they were being on
everything else, why hold back on this...if it was still
happening in their
time. QED, the system may have
dropped the idea back in the sixties.
v) Brace yourself everybody.
Dumping on gymnastics is one of the press's
favourite sports (here in the UK it's a bit behind
"Sack England's Soccer
Coach", but it's still well up there. Even
the Christy Henrich tragedy
crossed
the Atlantic with banner headlines). And these, BTW, are the same
papers who have just given zero coverage to Dortmund. From
what you guys
say, it's much the same on the other
side of the pond.
--
Frances
------------------------------
Date:
Sun, 27 Nov 1994 17:35:42 GMT
From: ***@achilles.demon.co.uk
Subject:
Soviet forced pregnancy accusation
I don't know how much the American
papers are saying on this story, but
I thought I better let you know there
has been another report on the
Karaseva story here. The source is "The Sunday Times"
(London). Interestingly,
(ominously?) yesterday's story was in the sports section. Today's is
in
the World News. For those unfamiliar with the UK
press, I should point out
that the Times and
Telegraph groups are probably the most authoritative
and
respected: i.e. reporting is pretty judicious and avoids the
sensationalist. I haven't seen other papers' coverage but,
if there is any,
(and the Telegraph and Times are
usually the only papers who cover
gymnastics at
all) it is likely to be less restrained and more in the
"gymnastics is bad for your kids" tradition.
BTW
everybody, don't think I'm enjoying posting this stuff. It's just that
I
reckon you'll want to know what's being written however disturbing it is.
Please
don't shoot (or flame) the messenger!
Title: Doctors confirm gymnasts'
secret
By-line: Tony Allen-Mills, Paris
"For years it was
only a rumour. Last week, for the first time since
successful
women athletes were suspected of
manipulating pregnancies and abortions to
enhance
their physical performance, a champion Soviet gymnast provided
confirmation of one of the most disturbing abuses in
sport.
Olga Kovalenko, a gold medal winner at the
1968 Olympic games in Mexico,
confessed to German
television that she had become pregnant and had an
abortion
shortly before the competition to toughen her body and profit from
hormonal changes that enhanced her physical
performance.
Kovalenko, who competed under her
maiden name, Karaseva, claimed that the
practice was widespread among champion Soviet athletes
during the 1970s. She
said girls as young as 14
were ordered to have sex with their coaches if
they
had no steady boyfriend. In her own case, she added, "I was told that if
I refused I would not have been sent to the Games".
The potential
benefits of the hormones produced in early pregnancy have long
been recognised by sports medicine
specialists. A French expert, Dr.
Jean-Pierre de Mondenard, noted last week that during the first three
months
the mother's body generates a natural
surplus of red corpuscles rich in
haemoglobin.
These
assist cardiac and lung performance and improve muscle capacity by up
to 30%. A pregnant woman also secretes increased amounts of
progesterone, a
hormone that makes muscles more
supple and joints more flexible.
Suspicion that women athletes from the
former Soviet Union planned abortions
to coincide
with important competitions first surfaced in 1956 at the
Melbourne Olympics, then eight years later in Tokyo. One
estimate at the time
suggested that as many as 10
of 26 medal winners may have manipulated their
pregnancy.
According to de Mondenard, no conclusive proof of
abuse was ever
produced.
The issue surfaced
again in the mid-1970s in an Italian swimming magazine,
Il Mondo del Nuoto, which accused Soviet and Scandinavian swimmers of
resorting
to abortions. Soon after, a Swedish
magazine, Aktuellt, published purported
confessions by a Swedish doctor and a Finnish masseur who
said the practice was
commonplace, especially
among athletes from what was then East Germany.
In 1988 a Swiss professor
of gynaecology told a conference in Strasbourg that
women athletes "interrupt their pregnancy
between the third and sixth month,
the principle
being that sporting performance augments as long as the
pregnant
woman doesn't gain weight"."
The only comment I want to add
here (I added plenty yesterday) is that I
didn't
like the title of this piece. Most of it refers to athletes in general;
not specifically gymnasts. So
the title should read either "athletes' secret"
or "gymnast's secret" (i.e. gymnast singular, not
plural).
--
Frances
------------------------------
Date:
Sun, 27 Nov 1994 13:50:21 -0800 (PST)
From: ***@netcom.com
Subject:
Soviet forced pregnancy accusation
>
> I don't know how
much the American papers are saying on this story,
It hit a few weeks
ago and has long since been forgotten here in the USA.
{...}
>
sensationalist. I haven't seen other papers' coverage
but, if there is any,
> (and the Telegraph and
Times are usually the only papers who cover
> gymnastics
at all) it is likely to be less restrained and more in the
> "gymnastics is bad for your kids" tradition.
AGAIN ?!? (Groan ...)]
>
BTW everybody, don't think I'm enjoying posting this stuff. It's just that
>
I reckon you'll want to know what's being written however disturbing it
is.
> Please don't shoot (or flame) the messenger!
Its good to know what is being said about our sport.
Remember
one of the important rules of combat. KNOW your ENEMY !
That
way you can deal with his attack when it hits.
Being taken by surprise is
NOT fun !
Thanks for the "Heads up !"
> Title: Doctors confirm gymnasts'
secret
> By-line: Tony Allen-Mills, Paris
>
> "For
years it was only a rumour. Last week, for the first
time since successful
{...}
> Kovalenko,
who competed under her maiden name, Karaseva, claimed
that the
> practice was widespread among
champion Soviet athletes during the 1970s. She
> said
girls as young as 14 were ordered to have sex with their coaches if
> they had no steady boyfriend. In her own case, she added,
"I was told that if
> I refused I would not have been sent to the
Games".
Man I bet "HARD COPY" would have LOVED this if
it had happened here ?
Poor girls... what if
the coach is ugly ?
{...{
I dont even want to think of what they did to the guys ....
> The only comment I want to add here
(I added plenty yesterday) is that I
> didn't
like the title of this piece. Most of it refers to athletes in general;
> not specifically
gymnasts. So the title should read either "athletes' secret"
>
or "gymnast's secret" (i.e. gymnast
singular, not plural).
>
> --
> Frances
>
------------------------------
Date:
Sun, 27 Nov 1994 01:56:12 -0500 (EST)
From: ***@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu
Subject:
Worlds
Hello! I just got back to Columbus after the trip to Dortmund and a stay
in NY (where I got to meet Adriana and Debbie -
an added bonus!). Since it's
1 a.m. right now, I'm too tired to write much,
but I'll add some things to what
Billy said in his reports. In my opinion,
in both the men's and women's
competitions, the
results came out right for that particular day. But I have to
say that the Russians beat themselves. The men were doing
great through the
first 4 events, but then for TV
purposes (German TV broadcast the finals
live),
on the last 2 events the gymnasts had to perform one at a time. Granted,
each team was forced to wait around a long time, but this
seemed to rattle the
Russians the most. They more
or less self-destructed on p-bars and high bar,
while
China hit everything. Nemov told me at the banquet
that the "pause" broke
the Russian team's
momentum, and he was very upset about it. He said he
couldn't
sleep all night after the loss to China. He wouldn't have been as
upset if Ukraine or Belarus had beaten them (there is still
a lot of
comaraderie
among the ex-Sovs). Also, when Voropayev
fell off high bar the 2nd
time, he just walked
off the podium crying. I felt really bad for him. Arkaev
spent the rest of the last rotation staring
across the arena at the Chinese on
pommels. Maybe
he was trying to "will" them to fall. But they were super clean
and definitely deserved the gold.
The women's
competition was kind of a similar story. To me, at least, it
was obvious that the gold was going to be given to Romania.
Earlier in the
week, we interviewed Svetlana Khorkina, and she was very upset about the
scoring, particularly Romania's and the USA's compulsories.
They competed in a
later round than Russia, and
benefitted greatly from that. At one point
Svetlana said something like,
Why should we even bother to compete when all it
is
is a game among the judges? A very
valid question. She also said that it
seems
to her that no one likes Russian gymnastics anymore. I think the team was
pretty demoralized because of the scoring and also losing
Natalia Ivanova, who
broke
her foot the day before competition began. They were then forced to use
Lebedeva, who really isn't that good by Russian standards,
and the judges were
not fooled by the ploy of
putting her up last. Again, for TV purposes, during
the
last 2 rotations the girls performed one at a time. Russia's last two
events were bars and beam, and they seemed to just crack
under the pressure.
Roshchina was up first on
both events, and fell on both events. On bars she
does
a Tkachev, giant, Marinich
(I know that's not the right name for the
girls',
but I don't remember how to spell the correct version), and as she's
swinging back toward the low bar she does a full twist. She
hit it in the
qualifying round but fell in
finals. She also fell on her beam mount, and
Grosheva
was uncharacteristically wobbly. That's basically what cost them the
silver. Meanwhile, the US girls were SOLID. I was extremely
impressed with
Jaycie Phelps, who had a
fantastic meet and was very well received by the
judges.
Amy Chow also recovered remarkably well from her disastrous performance
in optional qualifying (3 falls on beam, and she sat down
both vaults) and
nailed everything in finals.
That was great to see.
Had there been an AA,
it would have been (1) Milosovici (2) Khorkina and
(3) Dawes. I personally thought Lilia Podkopayeva was the best gymnast there,
but she had a fall in finals. She has a new floor routine,
which is kind of
like Kalinina's
- it starts out slow and classical and then turns into a
jazzercize sort of thing, but
she's so cute she can get away with it. :) The
Russians' new floor
routines were not what I had been hoping for. Too cutesy
(except for Kochetkova). Oksana Knizhnik (UKR) has a GORGEOUS new floor-ex,
very ballet-like. That was the style I was hoping the
Russians would go for,
but...
Susan, Joe (an NBC
researcher) and I interviewed Shcherbo, Belenky,
Korobchinsky, and Nemov, and John Crumlish and I
did the Khorkina interview,
which
I think John said will be in the February IG. All of them were extremely
cooperative, friendly and open. I think the Korby interview will be in "Gym
Stars." His
personality has changed drastically since '91, when I last
interviewed him. All the former arrogance is gone, and he
was very pleasant and
friendly. If anyone wants more
details on the interviews, let me or Susan know
(she's got them on audiotape). I'm too tired to remember
everything right now!
We also learned some interesting things at the
banquet. Nemov is already
planning
ahead and trying to figure out how to get a contract in the US. He
said he's trying very hard to learn English (he already
speaks it quite well,
but is shy about using it).
He must have been having a bad day in Brisbane when
he
refused to sign any autographs, because in Dortmund he was friendly as can
be. During the "official" interview he
was very soft-spoken, but in regular
conversation,
he's really open and fun and has a great sense of humor. As does
Karbonenko - he struck me as the team clown.
Well, I've already
written more than I planned to, and I'm afraid it might
be
a little incoherent since I'm very tired. Sorry about that! Let me know
what
else you want to hear about, and I'll try to
fill you in.
Beth
------------------------------
Date:
Sun, 27 Nov 1994 09:55:41 -0500 (EST)
From: ***@minerva.cis.yale.edu
Subject:
Worlds
> Roshchina was up first on both
events, and fell on both events. On bars she
> does
a Tkachev, giant, Marinich
(I know that's not the right name for the
> girls',
but I don't remember how to spell the correct version), and as she's
The
official name for the UB version of this skill is actually "Kim" as
in
Kim Gwang-Suk. The official HB name is "Xiao"
for Xiao Ruizhi.
It is
often referred to as a "Marinich" because Vitaly Marinich was one of the
first
(the second?) to do it and was instrumental in popularizing it, so
I guess
there was some confusion as to who did it first.
:)
Adriana
------------------------------
Date:
Sun, 27 Nov 1994 10:36:05 -0500 (EST)
From: ***@mhc.mtholyoke.edu
Subject:
Worlds
Any comments about Kerri Strug?
Has she changed for the better(or worse)
since leaving Steve Nunno's gym? I
was really impressed at the World
trials by how
quickly she was able to come back from that *bad* fall that
kept her out of Nationals.
------------------------------
End
of gymn Digest
******************************